A sermon from Pastor Tom at Mount Calvary Lutheran Church in Eagan, Minnesota | Matthew 25:14-30Watch the sermon on YouTube here
Key takeaways
The parable of the talents is about more than money or volunteer hours.
Jesus tells it during Holy Week, in the middle of an argument about who God really is.
God gives us gifts of love, grace, and compassion so we can use them for others.
There is no law against love, and together we can do what none of us can do alone.
It’s not just a stewardship lesson
A couple of things to start. Most of the time when we hear this lesson, it’s during a fall stewardship campaign. If you’re relatively new to a congregation, stewardship is the time of year when we look at the coming year and ask you to fill out pledge cards. Some of you are still doing that, and thank you to those who have. We talk about how to invest your talents and your abilities. We put out sign-up sheets. If you read, serve communion, sing in the choir, teach Sunday school, or do any number of other things, we ask that you give of your time. All of that is to say thank you for doing those things, and thank you for your generosity.
It’s not a secret that the people who work in this building have bills to pay, too. Part of what a congregation does is pay salaries and utilities. Mount Calvary does not have a mortgage, so you’re not paying for that. Good on you. You didn’t bury that talent in the ground. But it takes money to have a congregation, and we just have to get that out in the open.
The problem with using this lesson only in that way is that anytime we hear about the talents, we immediately make the jump in our heads to talking about money again. I think Jesus is talking about something much more important. When he tells this parable, this story, this allegory about what it means to be gifted with things and how to invest and make use of them, it’s about much more than our financial resources or our time. I’m sorry to say we have shrunk the meaning of this text so often that when you hear it, that’s what you assume.
Why this parable lands differently
There are some important things going on in the timeline of Matthew’s story. Matthew is the most Jewish of the Gospels. Near the end of this parable, the wicked slave is thrown into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. For Lutherans, and for Protestants generally, those who rely on grace, whose primary lens for talking about scripture is grace, mercy, and forgiveness, hearing Jesus tell a story where some people are thrown into outer darkness doesn’t land well.
For the Jewish people for whom this text was originally written, it would have been different. They understood that there were consequences for not following the laws God put forth. They knew the stories in their bones. When the people were out in the wilderness, after they had been led out of slavery, they didn’t trust that God was still with them. They built a golden calf and began to worship it. If you remember the story, Moses gets so angry that he smashes the original Ten Commandments and has to go back up the mountain for another set. We don’t know if God changed the rules at some point, but we have a whole new set of rules for the game. When he smashes the commandments, the earth opens up and literally swallows some of the people. This is the God of the Old Testament that people were familiar with, a God who could destroy cities like Jericho when the people marched around it seven times, blew their trumpets, and the walls came tumbling down. As Lutherans, we don’t tell this story that way very often. But the Jewish people understood that there were consequences to their actions.
Holy Week and an argument about who God is
At this moment in the story, Jesus is talking to his disciples, but this is during Holy Week. If you remember, on Palm Sunday Jesus rides into Jerusalem. The people come out in droves. They throw their coats and outer garments on the ground and wave palm branches, and they celebrate. Jesus is the Messiah who had been long awaited, from the house of David, who would save them not just from themselves but from the Roman occupation, from sin and death, and from a world that had forced them further and further down the ladder. It was going to be freedom. It was going to be celebration.
A lot of people turned out and celebrated. But in the crowd there were also Pharisees and Sadducees, Jewish religious leaders who were used to teaching the religion in the way they knew it. They were trying to help the people, too, but they had gotten things twisted. They watched and listened, and they were angry, and they began to plot.
For the next few days, Jesus goes out to Bethany at night, where he sleeps, about an eight-mile walk, so he is walking back and forth all the time. Every time he comes back into Jerusalem, he runs into the Pharisees or the Sadducees and has an argument. The argument always centers on who God really is. Is God a God of judgment and vengeance, a God who doesn’t always extend a hand or an olive branch or some way for people to come back? Or is God a God who always offers grace, mercy, and forgiveness? The Pharisees and Sadducees had made quite a living off keeping people afraid of who God was.
Jesus had spent three years trying to break down those walls. He healed people. He fed people. He welcomed back people who had no real right to believe they could be welcomed back. He took in people who had done things against their neighbors. He took back in people who were ritually unclean. He broke all the rules about cleanliness and offered these people a way back in. Over and over, Jesus demonstrated that God was not a God to be feared. God was a God to whom we open our arms, and we let God heal us, because God desires healing, wholeness, life, grace, and joy.
God is not meant to be feared. God is meant to be welcomed into our hearts, so that we open up and hear again that God loves us. God gives us abilities, and God uses the abilities we have not just so we can have a good life for ourselves, but so we can help other people. We are given this body and this set of gifts and abilities so that we can love other people as only we can. Each of us, created uniquely, has a different way of loving, welcoming, and healing, but each and every person is given the opportunity to open up their heart, to heal, and to love. We can choose to be angry, and we can choose to keep building walls, but what God wants is for us to be healed and to love.
For this, the Pharisees and Sadducees began to plot to put Jesus to death. This kind of message is a problem for them. If people are motivated by love, care, and empathy, if people are motivated by the desire to care for and love other people, that is a threat to those in control. Those in control make their money and keep their power by keeping people angry at each other, by convincing us that our neighbors are not just our neighbors but our enemies. They convince us that people who worship differently, vote differently, or look different from us are somehow a threat to who we are.
When we take in that kind of message, it’s easy to become angry and judgmental, and it’s easy to become soured on the future and on our neighbors. It doesn’t just happen to everybody else. We are all susceptible to those messages when our defenses are down, or when we’re weighed down by grief, guilt, or our inability to make things change. It can happen, and it does happen to all of us. That’s what the rich and powerful, and leaders like the Sadducees and Pharisees, relied on. But Jesus was trying to break that up and show people there were different possibilities.
Three servants and one buried talent
So he tells this story about three servants whose master went away and entrusted them with varying amounts: five, two, and one talent. It was a gift, a kind of wealth, given to them to manage, and each was completely free to do with it what they wanted. When we get to the end of the story, the one who had been entrusted with one talent buried it in the ground. He thought the master was cruel, a man who reaped where he did not plant and gathered where he did not sow. He buried the talent because he was afraid of what the cruel master would do.
The others took a risk. They gambled.
Have you ever gambled for the sake of love?
A story about taking a risk
It was a long time ago now, about 26 years, when my wife and I were first dating. We had met at camp and worked together for a few years. We had spent an Easter together in southwest Minnesota, and we were on our way back to the Twin Cities. She was so upset, because her parents lived in Illinois and we lived in Minnesota, and we didn’t see them very often. During that weekend, with a big family, siblings, and cousins all around, she had really wanted me to find a time to pull her dad aside and say, “Would it be okay if I asked your daughter to marry me?” I didn’t. I was scared, probably, and there was no good time. She was convinced it wasn’t going to happen.
We were having these conversations and planning all these things. I had taken a check I’d received, and I still won’t tell her how much it was, and bought the nicest ring I could afford for the amount of money I had. You probably need a microscope to see it.
We were at my brother’s wedding in Tennessee, and I decided this was the time. Her birthday was the next day. We had a beautiful day. We went for a drive on the Blue Ridge Parkway and looked at the rivers. I talked her into going out on a rock and jumping into a river. She wasn’t going to do it, but there was only one way back from the rock: a helicopter, or you had to jump. So she jumped in the river. What a first date. What a memorable date.
Then we went back to Knoxville and ran into a couple of my mentors. I took her to campus and we talked to people at the University of Tennessee. We ended up on a hillside above Cherokee Lake right at sunset, a beautiful red sunset. Keep in mind that we had been talking about wanting to get engaged. We were sitting on a curb looking at the lake. We were the only people in the parking lot, talking about everything we had gotten to do that day, and she said, “This has just been a perfect day.”
I pulled out the line of all lines. I said, “This is a day I never want you to forget.” I pulled the ring out of my pocket and the words fumbled out of my mouth: “Will you marry me?”
I’ve laughed about it for years, because once the words came out, time stopped. I knew she’d say yes, and yet for me it felt like five years. She just looked at me with those big, beautiful eyes and said nothing. When she tells the story, she says she said yes right away. But there was that moment. Even though I knew in my heart it was what I wanted, and what she wanted, and that this was the beginning of all kinds of possibilities we didn’t even know about, there was a moment after the words left my mouth when I took a gamble, and it was excruciating.
Have you ever gambled with love?
What the talents really are
When we talk about talents only as money or time, we miss the fact that what Jesus is trying to teach is about a love that is rich and deep.
If you’ve ever sat by the bedside of a loved one and held their hand while they were dying, and taken in the full weight of what that means and how it feels, you know. I see your faces, and I know you’ve been there. If you’ve been battered by grief, and by all the desires to have spent your time differently, to have had more conversations or one more meal, and yet, if you have that love in your heart, even the worst of waves can’t shake it out of you.
If you’ve ever had the kind of love in your heart that makes you dig into your own resources, and someone comes to you with a need you can meet, if someone is hungry, or needs a place to live, or needs a visit, or needs a shoulder to cry on, you know what that love feels like and what it is to want to help.
If you’ve ever found yourself broken in spirit, or found your own body broken, and wondered whether you would ever get better, you know something else. A former pastor of this congregation used to talk about how, when she had migraines, she felt resurrected when they were done. If you’ve ever had a migraine, it feels like it’s never going to end. Have you ever felt in your life that things weren’t ever going to turn around, and yet somehow, surrounded by love and kindness, by people trying to put you back together, and by God trying to heal you through other people, you were able to get up off the mat, up off the floor, and live again?
How much is that love worth?
The Pharisees and Sadducees in this story had just the littlest sliver of understanding, one little bitty talent. They were trying to convince people that God was cruel, that God wanted people angry, separate, and divided against each other.
That kind of teaching is still out there. It’s still twisted. You can still hear local pastors in our area talking about our Somali neighbors, for instance, or about trans people. When I think it all boils down, it’s really about not being able to see that God is a God of love.
If we have been given this love to hang on to, to steward, to manage, and to take risks for, then we are expected to put it out into the world, to challenge ourselves, to gamble and take risks, all for the sake of love. That’s true even when we find ourselves in excruciating moments of pause, unsure whether we asked the right question, did the right thing, or loved the right people.
I tell you, in the story Jesus is telling, the ones who took the talents from the landowner, the master, the king, and gambled with them, the ones who took risks, were the ones welcomed into the joy of their master. They took just a little bit of love and tried to see how much more love they could make in the world.
God has filled your heart
I think that is still our task, as a congregation and as individuals. I can’t tell you how it plays out in each of your lives. But I can tell you that God has filled your hearts with good things: forgiveness, grace, mercy, empathy, compassion, joy, hope, peace, and love. God has made you that way, and given you that gift, so that you can use it as only you can, with the people in your daily lives: your friends, co-workers, classmates, neighbors, and the stranger on the street.
God gives you these things not so that we’re afraid and bury them because we think God is a cruel taskmaster. God looks at the risk these servants took and celebrates.
There’s no law against love
Did you know that God doesn’t make any laws against love, against loving people? There is no rule against taking the love in your heart and giving it to as many people as possible. What’s beautiful about congregational life, and why we gather and pull our resources together to try to make things happen, is that you are able to do together what you cannot do on your own.
You couldn’t house 36 veterans and their families if you tried to do it by yourself. You couldn’t feed everybody by yourself. But as a congregation, you helped start The Open Door, which began in the basement of this very building, and now thousands and thousands of your neighbors are fed every month because of the generosity of many.
We have no idea what the next opportunities will be that God puts in our path, to take the love and the talents we’ve been given, as individuals and as congregations. But I do trust that God is going to want us to keep taking risks and keep gambling on love, for the sake of love. It might not always feel like it makes a difference, but you know in your hearts that it does. The times you have received grace and mercy, the times you’ve been on the receiving end of generosity that saved your life, it mattered to you. I’m telling you, friends, it matters to the world around you.
So we want to keep trying to be the kind of congregation that encourages each other to take the love and goodness in each of your hearts and bind them together, so that we can do greater things and keep making as big a difference in the world for as long as we can. Nothing is promised to us, no amount of time, as individuals or as a congregation. But friends, let’s keep being the kind of people who take risks and take those gambles, all for the sake of love.
Thank you for using your talents, your abilities, and who you are to love. Amen.
Join us for worship in Eagan, Minnesota
Mount Calvary Lutheran Church is an ELCA congregation at 3930 Rahn Road in Eagan. All are welcome.
Sundays: Coffee and donuts at 9 a.m., worship at 9:30 a.m.
Wednesdays: Supper at 5 p.m., worship at 6:30 p.m.
Online: Watch live at youtube.com/mountcalvaryeagan

